skip to nav

Technology is not enough

Right up to the point when someone thought a 17-ton armoured vehicle was the right negotiating tactic to spring two British special forces operatives from an Iraqi jail, the fact that two SAS troopers were disguised as locals (and sneaking around in a civvy car) showed the British Army was doing what it has always done, usually pretty well: getting down and dirty with the locals and gathering information.

The Army is struggling to win the intelligence battle. When your enemy communicates through use-once-and-throw-away mobile phones, or motorbike couriers, when you don't speak the language, and the locals are all related, come from the same village, and won't talk to strangers, gaining actionable intelligence is very hard. Hence the covert ops.

And technology won't help.

ben rooney on
the challenge
of gathering intelligence in Iraq

Faced with the language problem, the US bought electronic translators. The British hired teachers.

Much is made of lads from Bolton in slouch hats kicking a football with street kids from Basra. Great PR, but most importantly one game of football is worth more than the annual output of the entire US National Reconnaissance Office.

When your threat is a man with an AK47, spy satellites aren't going to tell you that someone has moved into the empty house next to the centre-forward's cousin.

This is nothing more than good old-fashioned policing - the Bobby on the Beat, albeit with a 155mm howitzer on call. What the British Army - and even more so the American forces - need is far fewer Rambos and a lot more Jack Warners.


Ben Rooney is a former army officer who has served in the Middle East

News & Comment: News & Politics