skip to nav

Sarah Palin’s intervention backfires for Republicans

Alaska Governor Sarah Palin

Candidate backed by Glenn Beck, Rush Limbaugh and the former Alaska governor loses to Democrat

FIRST POSTED NOVEMBER 4, 2009

So much for Sarah Palin and the plans to rebuild the Republican party in her image. The former vice-presidential candidate’s intervention in the choosing of a candidate for yesterday’s special congressional election in northern New York state has backfired. As a result, the staunch conservative Douglas L Hoffman, backed by Palin and other right-wingers including the TV personalities Glenn Beck and Rush Limbaugh, had to concede defeat this morning to Democrat Bill Owens.

With 88 per cent of the vote counted in New York congressional district 23 – an area abutting the Canadian border - Owens was leading with 49 per cent and Hoffman trailing on 45.5 per cent.

There has been no comment so far from the original Republican candidate, Dierdre Scozzafava, who would have been Owens’s contender had Palin and others not stuck their oar in and demanded a less liberal candidate.

Scozzafava supports abortion rights and gay marriage - two bugbears for Palin and Co - and has even backed President Obama's stimulus package. In short, she was considered by some Republicans to be far too close in her politics to Owens. Proving their point, Scozzafava eventually pulled out of the race on Saturday and threw her weight behind the Democrat.

Hoffman, as well as getting Palin's support, and being egged on by Beck and Limbaugh, was backed to the tune of $1m by the so-called Club for Growth, a group that promotes limited government and lower taxes.

The NY23 seat became vacant after President Obama appointed the long-serving Republican congressman John M McHugh as secretary of the army.

Bill Owens's win provided a rare moment of pleasure yesterday for the Democratic party, which suffered defeat in other key local elections being held a year on from Barack Obama’s presidential victory.

BLOOMBERG WINS AGAIN
New York City mayor Mike Bloomberg won a third term, but only just. Having poured $90m of his own considerable fortune into the campaign, he and the media had expected a landslide. Instead he beat the Democrat William C Thompson by a tight margin. "Everybody was shocked," a Bloomberg aide told the New York Times.

It appears voters were turned off by Bloomberg's "heavy-handed" and "self-serving" re-writing of the law that would have limited him to two terms. Bloomberg was too arrogant and too smug, according to some voters interviewed yesterday.

CHRISTIE TAKES NEW JERSEY
In the day’s biggest blow for the Democrats, Christopher J Christie won the race for Governor of New Jersey against the unpopular incumbent Jon S Corzine. The Republican overcame a massive Democratic voter advantage to win.

The 47-year-old former federal prosecutor, who heightened his profile this summer when he took on a corruption case which resulted in a series of arrests of politicians and others, said afterwards: "We are in a crisis; the times are extraordinarily difficult, but I stand here tonight full of hope for the future. Tomorrow begins the task of fixing a broken state." 

FIRST POSTED NOVEMBER 4, 2009

Filed under: Sarah Palin, Rush Limbaugh, Glenn Beck, United States, Barack Obama, Republican Party, Democrats, US election

Add to:

Comments

Hide comments

I'd like to see her versus a polar bear. A fair fight, no weapons.

Posted by Neil McGowan at 8:58am on November 4, 2009

All things considered, the President and the Great American Public came out of this pretty well. As you make clear, the main losers were the Palinistas of the weirdo Right. Bloomberg (by no means a disaster for NYC) had his wings severely trimmed. No bad thing. The least unpopular candidate took the NJ Governorship: no great surprise. What was perhaps surprising is the length of Chris Christie's coat-tails (consider the results in his home territory of Morris County). With Corzine's "legacy' (and Christie's timely prosecution of the corruption in NJ local government) it's hard to see this one as a straight vote on things economic (despite the HuffPo headline). Nor was the Palin automated telephone canvassing of any local significance (except to improve the local mirth-factor): NJ had to be a GOP winner from way back. The NY 23rd is the stunner. When will the GOP God-botherers recognise that FoxTV-endorsed ideological purity is not the only requirement in a candidate? There is a decent liberal-tradition in the Republican Party, of which this one is a useful prompt. Now can we also consider the California 10th? Democrat (Lt-Governor Garamendi) storming in by at least 16 percentage points. Wowza! No wonder Nancy Pelosi has an added skip in her step. All-in-all not a great day for the GOP.

Posted by Malcolm Redfellow at 11:07am on November 4, 2009

When did the First Post become a haven for Obama spinmasters? I must have missed the official Deification of Obama by His Holiness as I, like most Americans, have been too busy preparing for the eventual socioeconomic collapse brought on by Bush/Obama policies. The real story here is NOT the failure of Palin/Beck instead it is the growing power of the "Tea Party" movement. That an establishment hack like Scozzafava was run off the rails and the candidate of an obscure 3rd party, with no prior real political experience (and the personality of a "Glass of Warm Milk") came within striking distance of a well groomed professional politician backed by the State and National Democrat Machine. This was the voice of the electorate speaking...not Beck..not Palin...they just jumped on the bandwagon after it was moving The American People are coming to the realization that there "Isn't a Dimes Worth of Difference" between the two political parties... and THAT is the real story. Bad Journalists Need Not Apply

Posted by Glen George at 2:31pm on November 4, 2009

Add comment

You must be signed into your user account to add a comment.

  Forgotten password?
 
  or create an account

sign up for the daily email

People: People in the News