skip to nav

Conrad and the American way

Is Lord Black the victim of a new culture of envy in the US, asks margareta pagano

A Washington DC lawyer has written a powerful defence of the former Daily Telegraph owner Conrad Black, which paints the media baron as victim rather than fraudster.

The flamboyant Lord Black (right) was forced to resign three years ago as chief executive of Hollinger International after an internal investigation led to allegations that he had misappropriated $7m from the company.

With undisguised glee, the world's press pounced on Black and - with even more delight - his wife Barbara, excoriating them as much for their peacock vanities and lavish lifestyle as the alleged crimes.

Now Alykhan Velshi, writing for New English Review, an American online magazine, has lambasted the US legal system for destroying Black. He argues that an "insidious little worm" has distorted the US rule of law to

The government can ruin a man and make him a social pariah, all without securing a conviction

such an extent that it has ruined Black's empire and his reputation.

"The trial by attrition of Conrad Black has exposed the dark underbelly of the legal system, where the government can ruin a man, take his proper means of livelihood, and make him a social pariah, all without securing a conviction."

Although Canadian-born, Velshi says he has neither met nor spoken to the Toronto-based Black. He accepts that Black may well have been mistaken in running Hollinger as though he owned it all, but argues that this is not a crime and shouldn't be treated as such.

For example, Black may have been ill-advised to turn down a salary increase - taxed as income - and opt instead for management fees. But Velshi suggests these are technical and probably innocent issues. Indeed, he says, Black's old-fashioned proprietorial manner was important to the Hollinger brand and its success. It "hardly justifies the punitive lawsuits against him nor the pre-trial seizure of his assets."

Nor is Black anything like the late Ken Lay

News & Comment: News & Politics