skip to nav

Struck off three times – and still not out

Britain's procedure for vetting doctors is imperfect at the best of times - almost as porous as in Australia where an eighth medic was this morning arrested in connection with the British car bomb plots. No better example exists than Dr Maurice Raad, a chubby South African who in April 2001 turned up as our village doctor in Tasmania.

During his 22-day stint, before he was escorted to Hobart airport, Dr Raad sowed a trail of exceptional devastation, beginning with his injection - probably of sugar water - to my son Max.

The gravest case was a man with back trouble to whom Raad (right) administered a spinal injection. "The patient was paralysed for three days," a nurse told me grimly. "I dealt with him for the next 12 months, trying to stop him committing suicide."

Doctors can cross borders too easily, nicholas shakespeare knows from personal experience

The medical freemasonry, whether in Britain or Australia, is just as

protective as the Catholic Church, but it took only a phone call to find that Raad had been struck off the medical register in South Africa, not once but on three separate occasions. Eventually, I managed to secure Raad's medical files.

In 1982, Maurice Saadien-Raad, as he then styled himself, was 'purported to have performed an adeno-tonsillectomy on Nicolette Murtagh whereas the patient was subsequently found still to have tonsils'. He had attempted to perform a tonsillectomy on Nadene Vesta Kruger having 'negligently failed to observe that her tonsils had already been removed'.

He had also examined a patient complaining of severe menstrual flow 'without detecting a large cystic mass the size of a 16-weeks pregnancy in her abdomen'. In