skip to nav

A heavyweight that fails to hit the mark

ome novels, hefty and pumped full of fact, are like a work-out at the gym, demanding a good level of basic fitness. Human Traces (Hutchinson, £17.99), the latest from Sebastian Faulks weighs in at roughly a kilogram. You'd need to be really strong to read it in the bath.

You'd also need to be interested in 19th-century psychiatry, its subject. Its main characters are two friends, an Englishman and a Frenchman, who start out as medical students before having long careers in Vienna, intertwined personal lives, and endless arguments.

In the course of assembling this book, Faulks has obviously read a great deal, and he has shoehorned all his reading into the over-packed suitcase of his narrative. Some of it is lightly dramatised, but much of it still raw, distressingly undigested, pages and pages of lists and unleavened speeches, reading more like research

Sebastian Faulks’s latest is well researched, but
hard going, says lewis jones

notes than fiction.

At 614 pages, or about 250,000 words, Human Traces demands stamina. There were times when this reader felt like Sylvester Stallone, at his lowest ebb in Rocky III, reeling on the ropes. Still the relentless Faulks kept up his bombardment of facts, steady, heavy, slow.

There's a joke about only reading Playboy for the articles. Faulks's novels are a bit like the articles in Playboy - massively researched, earnest, worthy, too long, boring. But there are compensatory diversions. Admirers of his erotic writing (the lyrical rapture of which surely explains the sales of his Birdsong) will enjoy the exploits of Fraulein Katharina von A.