skip to nav
Thursday July 3, 2008

The West pulls up a drawbridge

There's an aggressive and a defensive Western reaction to this threatening world, both of which are mistaken, writes Timothy Garton Ash. Call them the crusader and the drawbridge options. The crusader option was Bush in Iraq. Now we'll see more of the drawbridge. Defensive, fearful, protectionist, shot through with a cultural pessimism worthy of Oswald Spengler, this variant says: pull up the drawbridge in front of the old stone fortress called Western Civ. Keep out as many alien people, goods, ideas as possible. Don't try to change the attitudes of Islamic states, Russia or China. Belonging to different civilisations, they have different values, and always will. The best we can hope for is a kind of armed truce, on the lines of "you do it your way, we do it ours". So this Western conservative view deplores multiculturalism at home but favours it abroad.
Timothy Garton Ash The Guardian

Tim Garton-Ash

Life without cars

Unless more economical, probably non-fossil fuel, vehicles are developed soon, private cars will be something that people in rural areas reserve for local pottering and others will keep – if they can afford it – for use mostly in emergencies, says Mary Dejevsky. Long-distance commuting by car, driving for pleasure, or even that popular move made by families from the inner city to the suburbs when the children start school, could become a thing of the past. In the United States, some planners already envisage a future where the country is essentially turned inside out, with derelict McMansions littering the landscape, and the outer suburbs, with no public transport and worthless housing, becoming the equivalent of today's inner-city slums.

Mary Dejevsky The Independent

The end of the Oil age

At the time of the last energy shock in the 1970s, Sheikh Yamani, the shrewd Saudi Oil Minister, famously told his greedier Opec colleagues that they would encourage replacement of oil by other energy sources and kill the golden goose that had made them wealthy if they kept pushing the oil price too high, notes Anatole Kaletsky. "Remember," he said, "the Stone Age didn't end because the cavemen ran out of stone." The last three global recessions - in 1974, 1980 and 1991 - were all triggered by an oil shock and it looks as if Opec is now determined to repeat this experience. How many such shocks will it take before we control our addiction to oil? An oil price of $140, never mind $200 or $300, is simply too economically damaging to be tolerated much longer. Anatole Kaletsky The Times
Why big oil is not to blame for fuel prices More

Filed under: Anatole Kaletsky, Oil, Energy
Anatole Kaletsky

The Conservative plan

We can book a tailor-made holiday on the other side of the world at a click of a button, writes David Cameron. Social networking can drive the environmental agenda. And Google can tell us more about our illness than our doctors. Yet we still have a government wedded to top-down state control. The future is people-led. Politics must respond - and with the Conservatives, it will. We will give parents the power to set up new schools. Once parents are more closely involved in how their child's school is run, they will take more responsibility for making sure it is a success. The same goes for welfare reform. We will give more power to charities and social enterprises that really know how to get people into work - paying them for their success.

David Cameron The Times

 

Rowan Williams - closet liberal

Dr Rowan Williams portrays himself as radically inclined, yet on homosexuality he has aligned himself with a conservative cause, writes George Walden. Sacred texts can be disputed, but all that matters is what the Bible would have said had it been known that homosexuality is largely genetic. How Christian can it be to deny men and women a sexuality that is, in Christian terms, God-given? Why does the Archbishop not say out loud what we all suspect that he believes? His views on everything from Israel to Afghanistan via a third runway at Heathrow airport are as forthright as they are predictable. To listen to the Archbishop, the infamy of US imperialism is unparalleled in human history, yet on gays in the Church he marches, if not shoulder to shoulder, in perilous proximity to the American Right.

George Walden The Times

sign up for our daily email

Enter your email address to receive our Daily Email in your inbox every weekday


You may have to register on the next screen if you haven’t signed up before.

ADVERTISEMENT

In Brief

Short-sighted science

The need to gain competency with science's underlying technical details means that we squander the opportunity to make students sit up in their chairs and say, 'Wow – that's science?' It's as if art classes consisted solely of learning how to perform individual little brushstrokes, without ever stopping to look at a painting by Caravaggio.

Johann Hari The Independent

Filed under: Johann Hari, Science

 

Why Sarkozy loves us

Nicolas Sarkozy is committed to the new French-British alliance, partly because Britain is the only real partner, in terms of military power, to advance European defence, which is foremost in his interests; and partly because he and Angela Merkel simply can't stand one another, personally and politically.
Anne-Elisabeth Moutet Daily Telegraph
Sarkozy's studio dramas spark overnight internet sensation More

Mutt inherits the earth

Everybody likes a dog. Except maybe a sheep. And every good dog deserves a bone. But $8 billion buys more bones than even the hungriest pooch could get through. At $4.50 a chew, Leona Helmsley's bequest could purchase 1,777,777,777 dog chews. More usefully, it could buy 800 million mosquito nets for the Third World. Or 80 million tents for homeless earthquake victims.
Leader The Times
Queen of mean's £8bn estate goes to the dogs More

Filed under: Animals, Money

Hushed about the money

It is odd that virtually every area of British politics is played out in public, or semi-public, from the setting of interest rates to the diplomacy in the build-up to war and on to the extensively reported stormy relationship between Blair and Brown. Yet few know what happens in relation to public spending until big, meaningless figures are announced at the end of the secret ministerial negotiations.

Steve Richards The Independent

What women want

In the last 12 months, films that were clearly targeted to women include Sex And The City, What Happens In Vegas, 27 Dresses, Made Of Honour, Juno, Forgetting Sarah Marshall, and Knocked Up. And now comes Mamma Mia! All of these films are about weddings, unplanned pregnancies, or both. What do women want? How about a story that suggests women might be interested in something other than being a wife or mother? Sarah Churchwell The Independent
This week's film reviews More

Filed under: Sarah Churchwell, Film, Women
Our news digests
  • Newsdesk
  • People
  • Business Pages
  • Opinion
  • Sports Page
  • Sunday Papers

ADVERTISEMENT